Homesickness for “The Philadelphia Story” and Other Fictions

If it weren’t for its title, you’d be hard pressed to pin down the 1940 film The Philadelphia Story to a location. True to the traditions of theatre and the Hollywood Golden Age, the film’s sets are few and mainly interior. Socialite Tracy Lord teeters on the brink of remarriage, with a catty-charming ex-husband, populist tabloid reporter, and absentee father descending on her parents’ mansion for the occasion. The beloved characters, expertly played by Katharine Hepburn, Cary Grant, and Jimmy Stewart, hardly venture beyond their manicured lawns. They speak in their famous transatlantic voices, the fine-bred, trained accents of no town and no country.  It sometimes seems that the film may as well have been set on the moon as in Pennsylvania—as long as there could still be fine drawing rooms and elegant patios, of course, for class conflicts play a much more vocal role in the film than regional color. The Philadelphia Story treats place much the way Tracy herself does: when Macaulay Connor asks, “Say, this is beautiful country around here. What is it all, anyway?” Tracy replies flippantly, “Oh, part of our place.” And on the story moves, as dismissive as Tracy herself.

old movie

And yet there’s something at once unique and familiar about The Philadelphia Story and other films of the era. When someone speaks in a quick patter, with a sideways quirk of the mouth, we recognize the accent of Golden Age cinema as certainly as we would our own hometown drawl. These films show a land of greyscale parlors crowded with lace and knickknacks. Night brings music; vowels and lighting alike are softened; champagne flows freely. These endless drawing rooms are populated by men with slicked hair and double-breasted suits accompanying women in high heels and cocked hats. These characters are wedded to this invented place—it feels as if they would crumble to ash if brought into the “real” world. But from the other direction, from the viewer’s point of view, the barrier is reassuringly permeable; I’ve never watched The Philadelphia Story without feeling actively welcomed into its world.

As I see them, The Philadelphia Story and films like it are a lesson to writers in creating place rather than simply reporting on it. Although it bypasses Philadelphia’s actual local flavor, the film is a loving portrait of the imagined space of the Golden Age screen—with its own ethos, accent, history, and regional customs. It is, as Tracy Lord notes, “our place,” existing only in fiction and yet real enough that the viewer can have deeply felt experiences there—can be almost nostalgic for it.

old movie

It strikes me that the vibrant and moving use of place in any work of fiction is at least partially dreamed up this way. In “Flood Control,” my goal was to evoke the spirit of a WPA-era Montana shantytown—an effort in which period research, though invaluable, could only get me so far. Even if I had walked the dirt tracks of 1936 Fort Peck myself, doing so would have been less than half the battle. The Philadelphia Story reminds us—and it’s worth remembering—that in privileging place in our writing, we commit to something rather more, or at least different, than straight journalism. We commit to evoking, for the reader and in ourselves, homesickness for an imagined world.

 

Olivia Wolfgang-Smith is the author of “Flood Control” in The Common’s Summer Fiction 2012 issue.

 

Photos from The Philadelphia Story

Homesickness for “The Philadelphia Story” and Other Fictions

Related Posts

Image of a field of wheat

What Matters Most

RACHEL LAVERDIERE
Where I'm headed, there will be heaps of food. After I packed my bag, I snuck past Maman pushing a tray of cinnamon buns into the oven. Yesterday, I overheard her on the phone with Mémère, “The chokecherries should be ripening soon.” Maman never lies.

Album cover for The Hold Steady

The Hold Steady Sets the Scene

ERIC R. DANTON
The song is less than five minutes long, with a wealth of imagery and emotion, and everything the characters are doing is so tied to a location that you could plot it on a map. More importantly, you can picture it: the lights on Michigan Avenue turning blurry.

Cover of The Open Heart Club

Hen Medic: Maude Abbott and the Dawn of Cardiology

GABRIEL BROWNSTEIN
October, 1931.  Imagine that you’re riding a southbound train from Montreal to New York City. The woman across the aisle smells strange, a mix of rose water and formaldehyde. She has packages everywhere. on the seat beside her, in the rack above.